Best Horror Games With Multiple Protagonists

Horror gaming can offer memorable and impactful experiences if those playing manage to resonate with the themes and gameplay that the titles are trying to convey. Sadly, it’s easy for games in this genre to rely more on shock value instead of a thought-provoking experience.

15:26

Related

The 86 Best Free-to-Play Horror Games on Steam (2025)

Those looking for the ultimate cheap thrill have come to the right place. Here’s a look at some of the very best free-to-play horror games on Steam.

So, when certain horror titles manage to tell a great story, they become all the more notable. This is especially true in the case of scary games with ambitious stories that are told via multiple protagonists.

8

Mouthwashing

A Nonlinear Narrative That Focuses On The PoV Of Two Different Characters

Despite being an experience that will take less than three hours for most players, Mouthwashing‘s impact lasts way, way longer than that. The story of a crew stranded in space after a crash makes for a nerve-racking time, especially when more information comes to light.

Players control Jimmy after the crash and Curly before it. This PoV shift makes for a fun twist later down the line as certain actions are contextualized, and a seemingly normal character turns into one of the most terrible people to ever exist.

7

Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem

A Mind-Bending Narrative Featuring Multiple Playable Characters

Technically speaking, players control Alex for the bulk of the adventure in Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem. However, while learning about a story that spans multiple lifetimes, the game shifts the PoV to other relevant characters.

It’s a simple and engaging way to tell a story that spans multiple eras, hammering in the all-reaching threat of a powerful ancient evil that threatens to destroy the world. The cycling protagonists ensure that Eternal Darkness will grab a player’s attention and keep them occupied for hours on end.

6

Alan Wake 2

Both Alan And Saga Star In Their Respective Chapters

Alan Wake 2 is one of the greatest survival horror games that fans of the genre can check out, with the sheer love put into this title making it clear why video game auteurs are more necessary than ever. This bizarre video game can feel downright surreal at times, yet this doesn’t detract from the amazing story it wants to convey.

8:51

Related

Best Horror Games On Xbox Game Pass (June 2025)

The Xbox Game Pass library is full of exciting titles, but remember to check out the best and most terrifying horror games in this collection.

It helps that both Alan and Saga are great protagonists to control in their respective adventures. Dealing with the Taken using firearms and a trusty flashlight makes for pulse-pounding gameplay as both lead characters do everything in their power to survive.

5

Resident Evil 2

Leon S. Kennedy, Claire Redfield, Ada Wong, And Chris Redfield Are All Playable

Resident Evil 2 is an iconic entry in the RE series, and countless fans were glad to see the remake do justice to the original title’s legacy. As one would expect from this series, the narrative is quite complicated and told via multiple PoVs, encouraging players to clock in multiple playthroughs.

After completing the Leon and Claire campaigns, the game surprises players by introducing two new characters to the fray. Both Ada Wong and Chris Redfield are compelling figures in their own right and make for a fun treat to control after players assume that they’ve seen everything this title has to offer.

4

Until Dawn

Players Control The Actions Of Multiple Teenagers Who Struggle To Survive

Gamers who want to check out a playable version of a teen horror movie will likely love what Until Dawn brings to the table. The story follows a group of eight teenagers as they arrive at Blackwood Mountain for a party, but things end up going south for them pretty quickly.

All eight characters are playable and can be saved as long as players are smart about using the Butterfly Effect to their advantage. This is easier said than done, however, especially since the threat of the Wendigos can be so nerve-racking that players may slip up, causing one of the teenagers to die a brutal death.

3

Sunless Skies

Every Captain Can Die And Be Replaced By A New Protagonist

Sunless Skies is one of the best narrative-driven horror titles that gamers can enjoy. Those who enjoy the simple vibe of horror media over monsters being chucked in their faces will likely love the amazing atmospheric exploration available in this game, which is a huge step above its predecessor.

2:40

Related

35 Best PS2 Horror Games

These horror games from the PlayStation 2 are the genre’s best titles from the console’s era.

The combat is real-time and frenetic without being too frustrating, and the multiple hubs ensure that exploration remains fresh and engaging. Death can be a pain in this game, but players will continue as another captain who can live out a different story if they end up encountering it.

2

World Of Horror

Multiple Protagonists Can Be Controlled And Unlocked Throughout This Roguelike’s Adventures

World of Horror is a fun roguelike take on solving horror mysteries in a world where a Lovecraftian entity will destroy the town of Shiokawa and bring forth an apocalypse. That is unless players do something about it. The mysteries are far from straightforward, and players are recommended to check out an easier difficulty if they don’t want to get frustrated early on.

Eventually, they’ll unlock numerous protagonists with unique traits, allowing them to tackle each run in a distinct manner. Players may even settle into a rhythm as they make a habit of thwarting the apocalypse, giving them the confidence to bump up the difficulty and make things more challenging.

1

Omori

Both Sunny And Omori Are Different Yet Two Sides Of The Same Coin

OMORI

Released

December 25, 2020

• 

While it may be true that Omori and Sunny are two sides of the same coin, there are certain spoiler-heavy reasons why they may as well be different entities. The emotionally distant Sunny is clearly trying to repress his trauma and prefers to escape into Headspace, where he takes on the role of Omori instead.

However, as players will Sunny to confront his fears, Omori stands in his way as this separate entity starts taking control. Depending on what players choose, they can either succumb to Omori’s influence or refuse to hide from their horrid actions as they finally take ownership of what they did.

More

Horror Games That Use Players’ Microphones

Using the player’s microphone in gameplay is an excellent way to increase immersion and tension in horror games. Here’s which titles did it the best.