Best Games With a Nemesis-Like System

There’s something oddly personal about watching a lowly grunt who once ran screaming from a fight rise through the ranks and come back with a new title, a fancy helmet, and a deep-seated hatred for your face. That’s the charm of a good Nemesis system. Whether it’s dynamic rivalries that evolve over time or recurring antagonists that hold a grudge like it’s their job, these games don’t just throw enemies at players; they give them enemies with grudges, scars, and the receipts to prove it.

While the Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor/War games are still the blueprint, several other titles have taken the concept and warped it into their own unique flavors. Some do it with procedural storytelling, others with squad politics or persistent villains who somehow keep surviving. Either way, these six games make every victory feel a little more earned—and every loss sting a whole lot deeper.

1

Middle-earth: Shadow of War

“I Know That Voice…” Said Every Orc Ever

Orcs that remember exactly how they were humiliated five hours ago? That’s not just a mechanic in Shadow of War; it’s the entire experience. The game took everything Shadow of Mordor introduced and inflated it like a bloodstained balloon, adding fortress assaults, rival tribes, and orcs who now come back from the dead just to gloat about it. One time, a seemingly dead Orc rose from a pit with a metal jaw welded to his face, muttering about betrayal like a Shakespearean villain. And yes, he had a title. “Gash the Undying.” It stuck.

But, what really made Shadow of War wild wasn’t just the variety of personalities or the absurdity of orcs holding grudges like middle schoolers; it was the way the Nemesis system tied directly into gameplay. Betrayals happened mid-battle, rivalries turned into power struggles, and dominated orcs could flip sides based on how badly they were treated. And, while the gear grinding and microtransaction controversy did sour things for a while, the core system remains unmatched in its scale and chaos.

2

Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor

Fire, Vengeance, and Orcish Career Advancement

Before its sequel threw in siege battles and orc poetry slams, Shadow of Mordor laid the foundation. It was the first time players weren’t just fighting enemies, but were managing grudges. Each Uruk had a name, a hierarchy, and a tendency to remember everything from the scar you gave them to how they managed to finish you off last time. And if they killed you? They leveled up. Got stronger. Got cockier. Maybe even rhymed about it.

The brilliance was in how unscripted it all felt. You could burn an orc in a fire pit, only for him to show up later with half his face melted off and an entirely new set of tactics. It was revenge storytelling at its most organic. And, since nothing in the system was hard-coded, each player had their own unique web of rivalries that spiraled into chaos naturally. Shadow of Mordor might feel smaller than its sequel, but in terms of raw mechanical impact, it changed how people thought about enemy AI.

3

Warhammer 40,000: Darktide

“For the Emperor!”… or Maybe Just Revenge

At first glance, Darktide seems like a co-op horde shooter set in the grimdark future where everything bleeds oil and screams heresy. But, underneath the chainswords and body horror, there’s a subtle social system that tracks relationships across missions. Fail a mission, and some of the bosses or elite enemies don’t just disappear; they adapt. Some encounters evolve, certain special units gain personality quirks, and player actions impact how recurring enemies interact.

What makes it more intriguing is how Fatshark used the game’s live-service structure to experiment with persistence. Updates have added mini-narratives and rival sub-factions that linger across story arcs. While it’s not a full Nemesis system in the Monolith sense, there’s still a sense of escalation. Veterans might recognize certain elite enemies by name or behavior, especially after several close calls. It’s all wrapped in 40K’s famously cynical tone, where even your own allies might start getting twitchy after too many mistakes.

4

Wildermyth

Heroes Die, but Their Stories Don’t

Few games handle character death with as much elegance and consequence as Wildermyth. Here, every warrior, mage, or farmer-turned-archer develops over time, not just through stats but through procedurally generated events. When someone dies, it’s not a checkpoint reload situation—it’s a new narrative fork. And if they survive too long? They can retire, pass on wisdom, or show up in a future campaign, scarred but wiser.

The Nemesis-like twist happens when villains or creatures become recurring threats. Maybe a monster kills a party member and escapes. In a later chapter, it returns, evolved, now with a bone mask and a personal vendetta. Or maybe a corrupted hero turns into a boss in someone else’s campaign. It’s all part of the game’s tapestry-like memory system that keeps past decisions alive. Instead of mechanical revenge, Wildermyth opts for mythic echoes, turning rivalries into stories that feel hand-written, even when they’re not.

5

Battletech (2018)

Punch an Enemy Mech Hard Enough, and It’ll Remember

Battletech doesn’t have a Nemesis system in the traditional sense, but it does something just as ruthless. Enemy pilots can survive battles, and if they get away, they can return—angrier, better equipped, and far more personal. That long-range sniper who disabled half your lance before retreating? Don’t be surprised if he shows up two contracts later, this time with a heavier chassis and a grudge.

Because combat in Battletech is turn-based and hyper-tactical, every unit matters. When an enemy pilot you’ve seen before appears, it’s not just cosmetic. They might target specific units, deploy smarter, or even mock your previous failure over comms. The mercenary contract system makes sure rivalries grow naturally, especially during the late-game when faction politics and past missions collide. It’s slow-burn storytelling at its grimiest, and when a recurring pilot finally goes down, it feels like revenge baked into a strategy manual.

6

Watch Dogs: Legion

“Oi, That’s the Hacker Who Took Me Nan’s Drone!”

It doesn’t take long in Watch Dogs: Legion before some random Albion grunt you mildly annoyed returns the favor with a stun baton and a newfound hobby of being your problem. While the system isn’t advertised as a full Nemesis-style feature, it quietly simmers in the background. NPCs remember how DedSec operatives treated them. Help a civilian, and their cousin might become a recruitable hacker. Knock someone out in public? Their uncle might come after you later.

The brilliance is in how relationships persist through a web of interconnected Londoners. A character you dismiss might end up linked to someone important, and suddenly, the city feels less like a sandbox and more like a living spreadsheet of grudges. It’s not quite as dramatic as orcs with flame swords and revenge poetry, but it’s smart. Subtle. And, when a recruit you were sure would never forgive you ends up joining the resistance, it hits differently.